1 April 2025

'Enjoy cooking with gas? So do I': Councillor fights push to phase out gas in new Wagga homes

| Jarryd Rowley
Join the conversation
2
a man standing in front of a gas stove, with insets of a woman and a gas stove-top burner alight

Cr Tim Koschel took to social media while using a gas stove to protest against a petition calling for new residential subdivisions to proceed without reticulated gas. Photo: Supplied.

Wagga Wagga councillor Tim Koschel has criticised a fellow councillor and a push to phase out the use of gas in new Wagga dwellings, after a community petition by the group Climate Petition of Wagga Inc signed by 198 people was presented to council last week.

The petition requests that the council consider allowing new residential subdivisions to proceed without reticulated gas. It follows a 2023 Notice of Motion presented to council by Greens’ Cr Jenny McKinnon asking council staff to prepare a report about the potential for the Council to put a stop to gas connections on new dwellings.

Environmentalists have argued that, because gas is a fossil fuel, replacing gas-fired homes with all-electric homes will help reduce emissions. The Victorian Government banned gas connections in new homes in its state in 2024.

The new petition has reignited the debate, with the council electing to receive a report on the potential benefits of a possible gas ban in new dwellings, much to the disapproval of Cr Koschel.

“We don’t need the report, I don’t need to see it and we shouldn’t be doing it,” Cr Koschel protested during last week’s Ordinary Council Meeting.

“Thank you to the staff that are going to take the time to write the report, but I think I’ve already made my mind up before reading [the report] because that’s where I’ll stand and I won’t be supporting it.”

READ ALSO ‘Food comes before power’: A 127-year farming legacy said to be under threat as solar farm moves in next door

Cr Koschel took to social media to continue his push in opposing the report, starting a petition of his own protesting against the ban and calling for anyone who agrees to sign.

“Enjoy cooking with gas? So do I,” Cr Koschel said.

“Unfortunately, after 198 signatures, it could be turned off just like that. Councillor Jenny McKinnon from the Greens tried to shuffle it through in 2023 with zero support, it didn’t even get a seconder.

“Now, surprise, surprise, the same thing’s come back again through a petition, it’s going to receive a report back to council.

“We need to stand up as a community and show the gas is our right and it’s our choice and it’s not the choice of the activists of Wagga.”

READ ALSO Is Australia’s renewable energy target making power more expensive?

Cr McKinnon expressed her disappointment with Cr Koschel’s decision to ignore the report, hoping that the seven other councillors would deliver a fair and rational debate after reading the document and before making their decision.

“I certainly hope that every councillor will make a rational decision,” Cr McKinnon said.

“I’m also aware that at that last meeting, a councillor made a comment basically stating that science is just an opinion.

“I don’t know what the council report is going to bring out, but even though that might happen, not everybody makes their decisions rationally. So I just hope that other councillors will give this a very sensible hearing.”

CORRECTION: The original version of the article incorrectly stated that the petition to council was initiated by the Greens Party and that Cr McKinnon called for a ban on gas on new home. This has been corrected to state the group Climate Petition of Wagga Inc initiated the petition and that Cr McKinnon’s motion was to ask council staff to prepare a report about the potential for the Council to put a stop to gas connections on new dwellings.

Join the conversation

2
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Wayne Carter7:36 pm 01 Apr 25

My mind is made up as well, especially when Jenny McKinnon cherry picks reports stating that an UNLIT gas trivet emits a carcinogen that aggravates a child’s asthma.
Jenny made this claim at a council meeting when putting forward a motion to stop natural gas connections to new sub-divisions nearly 12 months ago!
I know that a lot of people aren’t fortunate enough to live in a newly built home so they mightn’t know that when a new home is built to the Australian Standards (NCC) the builder will not receive a final occupancy certificate if any gas appliance isn’t ducted to the outside to disperse into the atmosphere.
Having natural gas connections available for a new sub-division is hardly a health risk because of the removal of gas fumes to comply with this standard. It’s much more likely a negative to have no natural gas to cook & heat with as sometimes the sun doesn’t shine & the wind doesn’t blow, but natural gas has been available as a clean & convenient fuel with no ramifications to your health for many years.
In fact, it would be more concerning for me to have a lot of our elderly & disadvantaged citizens to rely on electricity for cooking & heating because of the potential power dropouts & extra cost to heat your home on a cold winters night.
It would be wise to stop exaggerating how Australia’s climate is putting our citizens at deaths door because of (wait for it) less than 1% carbon emissions & poor timing to have the present government turn our energy grid upside down after the world had just been through the worst pandemic in a hundred years! This pursuit of net zero, when we as a country were & still are on our knees would have been so much less damaging when our country is in much better economic shape. As a result, we have record small business close downs & people sleeping rough which is shameful.
Please if you want to advocate for a cleaner world, knock on China, India & the United States door as they are the real polluters of the world.

Remote Leigh11:39 am 01 Apr 25

Koschel’s job regardless of his views is to “read the reports”. Proudly proclaiming his mind is made up
and doesn’t need to read the report is unethical and reeks of arrogance.

Daily Digest

Want the best Riverina news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riverina stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.