25 October 2026

Riverina Rewind: Why did a Wagga constable beat up a travelling preacher?

| By Chris Roe
Start the conversation
Wagga's Fitzmaurice Street in the 1920s near the Gurwood Street intersection.

Wagga’s Fitzmaurice Street in the 1920s near the Gurwood Street intersection. Photo: CSURA.

In 20th century Australia, the appearance of a “street preacher”, loudly proclaiming an ecclesiastical message to passersby in the middle of our towns and cities was not an unusual sight.

But on one fine spring evening in Wagga Wagga in 1928, a particularly loud espouser of the gospel attracted the ire of a passing constable who generated a national scandal when he collared the preacher and dragged him off to jail.

In the late 1920s the world was on the eve of the Great Depression and Australia was grappling with rising unemployment, industrial turmoil and economic tension.

As public unrest and radicalisation percolated, stump orators and street preachers would frequently appear on busy street corners, at markets and in parks to proclaim their message and argue the need for political or spiritual change.

READ ALSO Yenda man convicted after assaulting constable outside Area Hotel and for later offences at Leagues Club

On 9 October 1928, visiting 48-year-old Baptist Revivalist preacher Thomas William Brogan raised his bible on the corner of Gurwood and Fitzmaurice streets to deliver a fiery message of repentance.

According to The Daily Advertiser, a large crowd of between 120 and 200 people had assembled at the busy intersection by the time constable Loy pedalled his bicycle across the road to investigate at about 6 pm.

“He saw the defendant who was shouting. He had a book in his hand, which he was waving about,” the newspaper reported.

“Take a walk away,” the constable ordered, but Brogan ignored him and continued to “shout” and to gesture wildly with his hands.

Loy later told the court he had stood at the edge of the crowd for two or three minutes but “could not make sense of what Brogan was saying”.

After several bystanders reportedly complained to him about the noise, the constable gave the preacher a two-minute warning to move on.

According to witnesses, Loy then pushed his way through the crowd, snatched at Brogan’s bible and then clamped his hand over the preacher’s mouth and roughly pushed him to the ground.

As the pair grappled in the dust, a bystander laid his hand on the constable’s shoulder and was reportedly struck in the face for his trouble.

Loy was assailed by a chorus of boos and “hoots” as he hoisted Brogan to his feet and marched him forcefully towards the lockup.

Well-known Nationalist organiser Mrs Fourdinier was among the crowd and gave the constable an earful and demanded Brogan be allowed to walk on his own.

More than 200 protestors gathered outside the police station and the boos began again as Loy allegedly shoved the preacher forward to ram open the gate.

Once inside, the visiting revivalist was detained and charged with having behaved in an offensive manner.

“‘That will be all right,” Brogan replied.

“It is not the first time that I have been charged with a similar charge.”

When the matter was brought to court there was a long line of witnesses ready to defend the preacher, but constable Loy rejected claims he had been heavy-handed.

Under oath he stated he “did not catch the defendant by the throat and fling him to the ground” nor did he admit to striking the second man.

READ ALSO Riverina Rewind: Are there really Chinese opium tunnels under Wagga's streets?

Police Magistrate DF Parker was not overly impressed by the constable’s account and questioned whether the preacher’s actions could truly be considered offensive.

“There was evidence that he was obstructing the traffic but he did not think that waving the hands and shouting was offensive behaviour in this case,” reported The Daily Advertiser.

“He asked the police if they wished to change the charge to one of obstructing the traffic.”

After a short conference the police decided to throw in the towel and Mr Parker dismissed the charge with a final comment that Brogan had shown “extraordinarily bad judgment” when he “preached his doctrines at a busy intersection”.

Thomas Brogan may have picked up a few fresh bruises in the encounter but he left Wagga with a new set of clothes and a few pounds in his pocket after local sympathisers sent round the hat.

Free, trusted, local news, direct to your inbox

Keep up-to-date with what's happening around the Riverina by signing up for our free daily newsletter, delivered direct to your inbox.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Start the conversation

Daily Digest

Want the best Riverina news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riverina stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.